Stay up to date with notifications from The Independent

Notifications can be managed in browser preferences.

As it happenedended1568834205

Boris Johnson: EU gives fresh Brexit ultimatum as Supreme Court told 'mother of parliaments shut down by father of lies'

Judges in prorogation hearing urged not to let 'lies to triumph'

Benjamin Kentish
Supreme Court
,Adam Forrest,Lizzy Buchan,Ashley Cowburn,Chris Baynes
Wednesday 18 September 2019 17:04 BST
Comments
Supreme Court told 'the mother of parliaments shut down by the father of lies' in extraordinary attack on PM

Boris Johnson has been branded the "father of the lies" in an explosive Supreme Court hearing over his decision to prorogue parliament.

Aidan O'Neill, representing a group of cross-party MPs, urged judges "rather than allowing lies to triumph, listen to the angels of your better nature and rule that this prorogation is unlawful".

No 10 officials are reportedly concerned about how things are going in the hearing, fearing the judges will rule against the government and decide prorogation is a matter for the courts.

It comes after Mr Johnson was confronted by an angry parent during a visit to a NHS hospital. The EU’s chief negotiator Michel Barnier, meanwhile, accused the UK of only “pretending to negotiate” over Brexit.

Here's how we covered developments as they happened:

1568817612

Adam Forrest18 September 2019 15:40
1568818550

Former Scottish first minister Alex Salmond has said he would not have held the vote on independence in 2014 if he had known Boris Johnson would become prime minister and the UK would be facing the prospect of a hard Brexit.

Instead he said he would have delayed the vote - claiming this would have resulted in at least three-fifths of Scots backing independence.

He spoke out on the fifth anniversary of the independence referendum, when Scots backed staying in the UK by 55 per cent to 45 per cent.

He said: "If I had but known five years ago that Boris Johnson would become PM and Britain would be poised on the brink of a hard Brexit then I would have delayed the Scottish referendum and now looked forward to a 60 per cent plus Yes vote.

"In reality, it is probably the case that Scotland had to experience the fundamental shift of opinion in our first referendum before acting decisively to seize the day next time around.

"Therefore on this fifth anniversary we should focus not on what might have been but on the opportunity still to come."

Lizzy Buchan18 September 2019 15:55
1568819740

In impassioned closing remarks in the Supreme Court, Aidan O’Neill urges the judges: 

“Stand up for the truth, stand up for reason, stand up for unity and diversity, stand up for parliament, stand up for democracy by dismissing this government’s appeal and upholding a constitution governed by laws and not the passing whims of men”.

In an extraordinary attack on Boris Johnson and his government, he continues:

“We've got here the mother of parliaments being shut down by the father of lies. Rather than allowing lies to triumph, listen to the angels of your better nature and rule that this prorogation is unlawful - an abuse of power which has been entrusted to the government."

Benjamin Kentish18 September 2019 16:15
1568820277

The court has now been adjourned until tomorrow.

Lizzy Buchan18 September 2019 16:24
1568821036

Here's a clip of Aidan O'Neill's brutal takedown of the prime minister in the Supreme Court.

Lizzy Buchan18 September 2019 16:37
1568821968

Our sketchwriter Tom Peck has filed an absolutely brutal sketch of the prime minister's day.

He writes: "At the very moment the prime minister's barrister is arguing he did not lie to the Queen, the prime minister lies to a sick child's dad in a north London hospital."

Read his take here:

Lizzy Buchan18 September 2019 16:52
1568823092

Sorry Remainers, Corbyn will never oppose Brexit, writes Independent commentator Andrew Grice.

He says: "In a future referendum, Corbyn will likely refuse to support either side, casting himself as an honest broker who would implement the decision of the people. The danger is that he again falls between two stools"

Lizzy Buchan18 September 2019 17:11
1568824063

Sajid Javid has been urged to confirm when Mark Carney's term as Bank of England governor will end following speculation he could be asked to stay on to deal with prolonged Brexit uncertainty.

The Chancellor has been asked by the Commons Treasury Committee to confirm whether Mr Carney's replacement will take over on February 1 as currently expected.

Mr Carney's term has already been extended twice and the Financial Times newspaper suggested his departure could be postponed again if there was a further delay to Brexit.

The cross-party legislation aimed at preventing a no-deal Brexit on October 31 called for Boris Johnson to seek a delay to the UK's departure until January 31 if no agreement had been reached with Brussels, the date currently scheduled to be Mr Carney's last at Threadneedle Street.

A general election in the autumn could also derail the process of choosing a replacement for Mr Carney.

Lizzy Buchan18 September 2019 17:27
1568824980

Schools have been asked to explain their plans for ensuring there is enough food in case of a no-deal Brexit.

Education minister Lord Agnew has urged schools, councils and academy chains to contact suppliers to ensure they will be able to continue providing food if Britain leaves the EU on 31 October without a withdrawal agreement in place.

The letter, seen by the Times Educational Supplement (TES), asks the bodies to complete a survey by next week. 

More here:

Lizzy Buchan18 September 2019 17:43
1568825880

  ↵

Campaigners and survivors have criticised the government for refusing to say if the new domestic abuse bill will include “life-saving” provisions that were outlined in the original legislation.

Victoria Atkins, the Home Office minister for safeguarding, would not confirm whether the new legislation will ban the cross-examination of victims by their alleged abusers despite it being a key measure in the initial bill. 

The landmark legislation included a number of provisions that domestic violence charities had spent years campaigning for. 

More here:

Lizzy Buchan18 September 2019 17:58

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies

Comments

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in