MPs' expenses claims destroyed by House of Commons authorities

Evan Bartlett@ev_bartlett
Monday 03 November 2014 11:30
John Bercow, Speaker of the House of Commons

All MPs expenses claims from before 2010 have reportedly been destroyed by the House of Commons authorities.

According to the Telegraph, the newspaper that first broke the expenses scandal story in 2009, thousands of pieces of information have been destroyed in order to comply with data protection law.

Under the House of Commons "Authorised Records Disposal Policy", all MPs expenses claims are shredded after three years.

However, John Bercow, the Speaker of the House, now faces accusations that he has presided over another cover-up as there is now insufficient evidence to discipline MPs over bogus claims.

Under the same "disposal policy", MPs' pay, discipline and sickness records are kept until their 100th birthday, health and safety records are kept for up to 40 years and other pieces of information are kept indefinitely.

The Members Estimate Committee, which is overseen by Mr Bercow, called for the ruling to be scrapped in 2010 deciding that all MP expenses claims should be kept. However, in February 2012, the committee reverted that decision and opted to maintain the older policy, the Telegraph reports.

It sounds like MPs trying to protect MPs again. It will make the public very suspicious of what the motive is. The old gentlemen’s club is resurrecting itself.

  • John Mann, Labour MP for Bassetlaw

It is scandalous that anybody has destroyed the records for that period. Who knows what anybody’s motivation was.

The people concerned should know better. There was a strong public interest in retaining this information so that people have access to it, and I’m really very surprised.

  • Sir Alistair Graham, former chairman of the Committee on Standards in Public Life

A House of Commons statement said: “The Authorised Records Disposal Policy (ARDP) ensures the House of Commons is abiding by the Freedom of Information Act (2000) and the Data Protection Act (1998). Data protection legislation places an obligation on the Commons to keep information about individuals only for as long as it is needed and for the original purpose for which it was collected. Moreover, under Freedom of Information laws, it is necessary to know with certainty what information is held, what has been destroyed and on what authority destruction occurred."

"While original financial documents related to MPs’ expenses were destroyed in compliance with the ARDP, in June 2009 more than a million documents and receipts were published online and subsequently updated. This information remains available on the parliamentary website. These documents were redacted to ensure the House’s obligations under the Data Protection Act were met and security information remained protected (i.e. bank account details and home addresses).”

More: MPs told to curb raucous behaviour in order to make better television

More: Teachers demand MPs sign Hippocratic oath too