News
Conrad Duncan
Mar 07, 2021
Getty Images For RADIO.COM
The banjo player from Mumford & Sons has come under fire for voicing support for a controversial right-wing writer who has been accused of using misleading and inaccurate information to depict anti-fascist groups as violent extremists.
Winston Marshall shared an image on Twitter of Andy Ngo’s book Unmasked: Inside Antifa's Radical Plan to Destroy Democracy on Saturday afternoon, alongside a message of support for the writer.
“Congratulations @MrAndyNgo. Finally had the time to read your important book. You’re a brave man,” Marshall said.
Ngo has been accused of promoting a false equivalence between left-wing and right-wing political violence in the US, such that an article in Columbia Journalism Review in 2019 described him as a “discredited provocateur”.
Critics of the Portland-based writer have also alleged that he works with far-right groups – such as Patriot Prayer – that he purports to report on.
Meanwhile, Ngo has argued that he is a legitimate journalist and that much of the media is biased towards anti-fascist groups.
Antifa is a highly-decentralised left-wing movement which uses both nonviolent and violent direct action to challenge fascist and racist groups, such as neo-Nazis and white supremacists.
In response to Marshall’s tweet, some social media users pointed out that being opposed to anti-fascism puts you in a very dubious political position...
@MrWinMarshall Just out of interest, you do know the alternative term for being anti-Antifa?— Scrounge (@Scrounge) 1615064120
Meanwhile, the general response to Marshall’s endorsement of the book was overwhelmingly negative…
Real folk musicians worked hard and supported Folk Against Fascism. Turns out that fake folk musicians from Mumford… https://t.co/fyUK8TaeFO— John Spiers (@John Spiers) 1615108410
Privileged posh boy from shit band Mumford & Sons in “turns out to be a bit right wing” shock. https://t.co/5baO80zMtA— Simon Price﮷ (@Simon Price﮷) 1615107863
@MrWinMarshall @MrAndyNgo Honestly thank you for finally giving me a reason to delete the most embarrassing song I… https://t.co/GLNz5GCZrt— maura quint (@maura quint) 1615075164
@MrWinMarshall @MrAndyNgo Forgive me if I don’t take book recommendations from the banjoist in the mumfords— James Felton (@James Felton) 1615121848
@MrWinMarshall @MrAndyNgo 🎶 I will wait I will wait for Q 🎶— Ryan Beck (@Ryan Beck) 1615073683
However, as one user pointed out, we did have some prior warning for this - when Mumford & Sons invited alt-right darling Jordan Peterson to meet them in 2018...
nobody could've seen this mumford and sons thing coming https://t.co/p6c1w56LxI— Dan Hicks (@Dan Hicks) 1615112280
After facing criticism for that meeting, Marshall responded by suggesting that he did not necessarily agree with everything the academic had said.
The banjo player told CBC Radio:
“I primarily was very interested in Dr Peterson’s work on psychology, read both his books and found it very, very interesting, and met him [through] a mutual acquaintance and invited him down to the studio whilst he was in London on tour, which was very interesting and one of many interesting visits we had in the studio.”
He added: “I don’t think that having a photograph with someone means you agree with everything they say.”
More: Why Rihanna’s recent cultural appropriation backlash makes sense
Top 100
The Conversation (0)