Metropolitan Police advice that women should “run away” if they feel unsafe in the presence of a lone police officer has been met with a huge backlash, with people saying it puts the onus on women to keep themselves safe.
A spokesperson from the force said it is unusual for a single plainclothes police officer to engage with Londoners and that people should attempt to verify their “identity and intentions” if they do so.
But: “If after all of that you feel in real and imminent danger and you do not believe the officer is who they say they are, for whatever reason, then I would say you must seek assistance – shouting out to a passer-by, running into a house, knocking on a door, waving a bus down or if you are in the position to do so calling 999,” they said.
People also said the onus should be on the police, not women, to ensure violent criminals do not make their way into their ranks:
A spokeswoman for Solace Women’s Aid said: “Any man intent on causing serious harm or murder is unlikely to stop in their tracks if asked some probing questions, even more so a police officer who is in a position of power.
“Instead of deflecting responsibility on to women and creating guidelines to moderate their behaviour to keep themselves safe, the police need to say what they are going to do to address systemic misogyny in their own ranks and to rebuild trust with women.”
Refuge chief executive Ruth Davison said: “Time and again, the Metropolitan Police have responded to incidents of gender-based violence by telling women to change their behaviour.
“Time and again, the responsibility is placed on women to protect themselves.
“This is simply not good enough. Police forces across the country must be prepared for a fundamental shift and overhaul in their attitudes towards women and root out the misogyny that is at the heart of these failings.
“Refuge keenly awaits the Met’s strategy for tackling violence against women and girls. Women deserve better.”
This plays right into the vile culture of victim-shaming we so often see when women are assaulted.
It's not our jo… https://t.co/GZgnXNmvk8
— Bell Ribeiro-Addy MP (@Bell Ribeiro-Addy MP)
Feel like the onus should be on the police to make women feel safe, not on their own ability to fucking peg it https://t.co/UP9vI9MtfG
Solicitor Jon Heath from Levins Law explained that it is an offence under section 89 of the Police Act 1996 to wilfully obstruct a police officer in the execution of their duty.
“Case law confirms that a police officer who wishes to ask someone questions is executing their lawful duties, and hence that running away from an officer can amount to obstruction,” he said.
“If a woman were to run away through genuine fear that she was about to be abducted, one would hope that the police and the CPS would recognise that it would not be in the public interest to prosecute, but that cannot be guaranteed.
“Moreover, running away is not very practical advice — your average citizen will probably be caught, and possibly injured in the process.”
If “you do find yourself in an interaction with a sole police officer and you are on your own, it is entirely reasonable for you to seek further reassurance of that officer’s identity and intentions,” the force said.
And people pointed out that there have been times in which people have challenged the police, only for them to be shot at or arrested:
@LBC The family of Jean Charles de Menezes may take issue with advice to 'run away if you don't feel safe' coming f… https://t.co/PYC86mgsQB
The police spokesperson added that people who get stopped should ask “where are your colleagues, where have you come from, why are you here and exactly why are you stopping or talking to me?” and that it is reasonable to request “independent verification” like hearing the voice of another officer over the radio.
“All officers will, of course, know about this case and will be expecting in an interaction like that - rare as it may be - that members of the public may be understandably concerned and more distrusting than they previously would have been, and should and will expect to be asked more questions,” the spokesperson said.
If you want to learn more about your rights when dealing with the police, click here.