News
Moya Lothian-McLean
Jun 01, 2020
Twitter
At a protest in Santa Cruz, California, a group of police officers were pictured ‘taking a knee’ alongside demonstrators and Santa Cruz mayor Justin Cummings.
Kneeling, already a symbol adopted by anti-racism protesters thanks to NFL demonstrations, has emerged as an even more loaded act following the death of George Floyd.
Floyd died after a white police officer knelt on his neck for nine minutes.
In a tweet, the Santa Cruz police department said it was “fully supportive” of peaceful protests and would “always keep them safe”.
SCPD is fully supportive of peaceful protests @CityofSantaCruz and we always keep them safe. Hundreds gathered on… https://t.co/kOeLYY9lwO— Santa Cruz Police (@Santa Cruz Police) 1590873500
The tweet also explicitly cited “police violence against black people” as the reason for the protest.
Many social media users praised the Santa Cruz officers for their action.
It was called a “hopeful sign”.
A small but hopeful sign: The mayors of San Jose & Santa Cruz, the Santa Cruz police chief & police in Oakland and… https://t.co/oL1btycqLG— Carol Pogash (@Carol Pogash) 1590990908
And an example of “leadership”.
This is the kind of leadership we need. https://t.co/UcC0f3qrkq— ERIC BALFOUR (@ERIC BALFOUR) 1590897880
But others weren’t so easily swayed.
Many are arguing that it is not enough to simply have ‘good’ cops if the entire system is institutionally racist and oppressive.
stop (re)tweeting cop propaganda. there is no such thing as good, friendly, or helpful cops. there is nothing a cop… https://t.co/8rx2vvJMT4— real cat mom shit™ (@real cat mom shit™) 1590996613
So there were loud critics of the police taking a knee.
Especially those who had experience of SCPD policing methods.
Others said Santa Cruz was not an example to be held up.
It’s easy to do this in Santa Cruz. It needs to be said. There’s no joy in seeing my hometown touted around without… https://t.co/JhIjj7ZtB3— Coral Kamstra-Brown (@Coral Kamstra-Brown) 1591018270
One Twitter user called the image of officers kneeling “powerfully stupid”.
Cops protesting: powerful or performative?
The Conversation (0)
x