Politics
Kate Plummer
Jan 30, 2023
content.jwplatform.com
A Tory minister was left licking her wounds after Kay Burley expertly shut her down in an interview about Nadhim Zahawi.
Helen Whately was the latest MP to be dragged out to defend the government to the media this morning, after prime minister Rishi Sunak sacked Zahawi over his tax scandal on Sunday.
But she probably wished she has stayed in bed when she arrived at the Sky News studio and had a very tense exchange with Burley.
The presenter put it to Whateley that Sunak should have acted sooner, and said people were aware of Zahawi's dodgy tax affairs.
She questioned why civil servants didn't inform Sunak of the issue and after Whateley defended Sunak, Burley asked her to respond to the Lib Dems call for Zahawi to lose the Tory whip.
Sign up to our free Indy100 weekly newsletter
"He's been fired from government. This is a very serious consequence because he didn't comply with the ministerial code but he was still elected to be a member of parliament," she said.
She added: "We can talk about this but I will just say that I've come here to talk about something that I know that people really care about which is about the NHS..."
Speaking over her, Burley replied: "We will come to that, I'll do the interview, you answer the questions."
\u201cThe Cabinet Office knew about Nadhim Zahawi, but Tory minister Helen Whately explains the PM didn't know. When #KayBurley follows up by asking "Are you telling me civil servants.. would not have alerted the PM?", Whately repeats the fact that "the PM didn't know"\u201d— Saul Staniforth (@Saul Staniforth) 1675064205
Ouch.
It comes after Zahawi was sacked as chairman of the party following an investigation by the prime minister's new ethics adviser, Sir Laurie Magnus, which concluded that Zahawi had broken the rules by repeatedly failing to declare the now notorious HMRC investigation into his tax affairs that left him coughing up £5m.
Sunak wrote that his ethics adviser had concluded there was a “serious breach” of the ministerial code. “As a result, I have informed you of my decision to remove you from your position,” he wrote.
In response, rather than showing contrition, Zahawi moaned on about being “concerned” about the “conduct from some of the fourth estate in recent weeks”.
Later in her interview with Burley, Whately was forced to remind the minister again of the functions of interviewer and interviewee when the minister failed to change the subject to the NHS once more.
"We will talk about that [the NHS] in the fullness of time, I have eight minutes with you and I will decide how we conduct this interview if you don't mind," Burley said.
\u201cKay Burley shutting down Helen Whately this morning was just \ud83d\ude19\ud83d\udc4c\ud83c\udffb\u201d— Edd A-M (@Edd A-M) 1675064721
And elsewhere Whateley also had a terrible time facing the scrutiny of other broadcasters.
Speaking to LBC's Nick Ferrari, she came unstuck when she was asked why it was deemed acceptable for Suella Braverman to previously break the ministerial code but return to government while Zahawi was sacked.
Whateley mumbled about how she apologised and resigned at the time but said Braverman was needed to deal with one of Sunak's priorities - tackling small boats.
\u201c'Nadhim Zahawi is gone yet Suella Braverman breached the ministerial code and was reinstated just days later, can you explain that?'\n\nNick Ferrari puts Minister Helen Whately on the spot.\n\n@NickFerrariLBC | @Helen_Whately\u201d— LBC (@LBC) 1675065790
When speaking to Mishal Husain on BBC Radio 4's the Today programme, she was asked whether Zahawi having the whip sat "with difficulty" with her "given he has been found to make an untrue public statement" and fumbled again.
\u201cForensic interviewing by @MishalHusain on #BBCR4today. Care minister Helen Whately say it\u2019s fine for ex chancellor Nadhim Zahawi to retain the Tory whip, despite his repeated lies about his tax affairs, because \u201che was elected\u201d\ud83e\udd26\u200d\u2642\ufe0f h/t @HUncaring\u201d— Ian Fraser (@Ian Fraser) 1675073103
And on Good Morning Britain she showed she struggles with other topics too, when she was asked to speak about problems with filling vacancies in the NHS.
Take a look here:
\u201c'With 130,000 vacancies in the NHS do you have the staff to look after the people in those extra beds or those ambulances?' @susannareid100\n\nHealth minister Helen Whately says 'one reason why we've got vacancies is because they're expanding the services and recruiting more.'\u201d— Good Morning Britain (@Good Morning Britain) 1675067984
All we can say is we've definitely had better Monday mornings...
Have your say in our news democracy. Click the upvote icon at the top of the page to help raise this article through the indy100 rankings.
Top 100
The Conversation (0)