Fantastic Beasts: The big problems with Professor McGonagall's appearance in the sequel

Sunday 18 November 2018 16:00
news
Picture:(REX Features)

Once again Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald is in the public eye for all the wrong reasons.

Critics have been rather negative about the latest Harry Potter spin-off, mostly citing plot holes and a seemingly canonical oversight.

Minerva McGonagall briefly appears in the the film as a young-adult wizarding instructor at Hogwarts... in 1927.

The obvious problem there is that according to general Harry Potter lore, she wasn't even born yet.

Going off of information from the books and Pottermore, which is an online Mecca for all things Harry Potter, people have been quick to point this out.

Incidentally, Pottermore features original writing from creator J.K. Rowling which is generally recognised as official canon. That aside, in the original series Professor McGonagall first started teaching at Hogwarts in 1985, when she was 21 years old.

People have tried to argue that this Minerva is actually Professor McGonagal's mother, but this is entirely wrong because they had different names. Minerva's mother is supposedly a woman named Isobel who never taught at Hogwarts.

Others see her appearance in the film as just an error, but a popular belief is that it's part of some big plan which will be revealed at a later date.

Whatever the reason is, J.K Rowling. who is rather prolific on Twitter, has yet to weigh in on this and clarify to her dismayed fans as to what's happening.

More: This is the the biggest plot hole in Harry Potter

Trending