Surprisingly, at number two the Mythical Kitchen creator said he would take FarFetch'd and make a "lovely Thai duck noodle soup" because he comes with his own aromatics.
Finally, Scherer said the number one Pokémon he would cook is Snorlax because he has a lot of tenderloin fat which he could roast over charcoal and dip in sesame oil.
Commenters found the silly video very funny and agreed that while it was horrifying imagining Pokémon being cooked and eaten, he had made some good points about cooking.
"Gives a new meaning to " Poké Bowl", Gotta eat 'em all!," a commenter wrote on YouTube.
"Fun fact: Canonically in Pokemon Farfetch'd were almost hunted to extinction because they are known to be very tasty when cooked with their leeks," another commenter said.
With over two million views on YouTube and Instagram combined, Scherer attracted enough attention to make a part two and three to his Pokémon he'd like to eat series.
Scherer is part of Mythical Kitchen which is a branch of popular YouTubers Rhett and Link's Mythical Entertainment company. Each week he and his co-creators make videos trying to create foods from fictional worlds or create new foods.